A comparative study on UASB MF-OMBR and AnMF-OMBR treating slaughterhouse wastewater: Process performance, struvite precipitation, and economic evaluation

Up-flow anaerobic sludge blanket microfiltration osmotic membrane bioreactor (UASB MF-OMBR) is a cutting-edge technology derived from the anaerobic osmotic membrane bioreactor (AnOMBR). This study investigated long-term performance of an UASB MF-OMBR and an anaerobic microfiltration osmotic membrane bioreactor (AnMF-OMBR) comparatively focusing on process performance, membrane fouling, microbial community shift, struvite precipitation, and economic evaluation for the treatment of synthetic and real slaughterhouse wastewater (SSW and RSW). The UASB MF-OMBR achieved higher process performance regarding chemical oxygen demand (COD) removal (70 +/- 1 %), methane yield (0.24 +/- 0.03 L CH4 g(-1) CODremoved) and NH4+-N rejection (85 +/- 3 %). On the other hand, high COD and PO43--P rejections were observed in both systems (>92 % and similar to 98 %, respectively). The impact of the salinity build-up in the UASB MF-OMBR was the lower due to the bioreactor configuration. In addition, compared to the AnMF-OMBR, the better water fluxes were obtained in the UASB MF-OMBR, which can be attributed to the less membrane fouling. The results of precipitation modelling and Mg2+ measurement in the sludge of both bioreactors demonstrated that the struvite precipitation occurred during the forward osmosis (FO) operation was more often and in higher amounts in the AnMF-OMBR. The economic evaluation indicated that the specific produced permeate cost (SPC) with revenue was slightly lower for the UASB MF-OMBR than that of the AnMF-OMBR.